Skip to content

AI Overviews: how much traffic you're losing and how to get cited by Google

Milica Subotic18 min read

Bright sky blue and orange illustration: a river full of paper boats runs into a large speech bubble acting as a dam, and only three boats slip through a small door towards a shop on the bank

IN SHORT

When an AI Overview appears, clicks on organic results drop: according to Ahrefs, the top result has a 58% lower CTR on average; according to Pew Research, people click a link on 8% of visits instead of 15%. The losses are concentrated on informational searches. In Search Console, AI Overview data is mixed into the Web search type: to estimate what you're losing, compare expected and actual CTR by query group. Sites that get cited lose less.

Topic of our service GEO · Optimisation for AI Overviews and ChatGPT · industry B2B & Manufacturing

The marketing manager of a company that sells coffee machines opens Search Console at the end of October and compares the quarter with the same period a year earlier. Impressions are up 12%, average position has improved from 4.1 to 3.2, and yet clicks have fallen by almost a third. The pages losing the most are the guides: “how to descale a coffee machine”, “difference between fine and coarse grind”. The product pages are holding up. Nobody has touched the site. What happened?

The short answer: on many of those searches Google shows an AI Overview, the box at the top of the results with an answer written by artificial intelligence. Studies published in 2025 and 2026 agree on the direction: when the box is there, clicks on organic results fall, by more than half for the top result in some analyses. The drop is concentrated on informational searches and weighs less on commercial and branded ones. In Search Console, AI Overview data has no separate filter, but you can estimate the loss by comparing expected and actual CTR for groups of queries. And sites cited as sources lose less than those left out.

This article focuses on the numbers: how much is lost, how to measure it, what to do about it. How generative engines work and what GEO is are covered in our guide to Generative Engine Optimization; the technical and content checks are in the SEO checklist for AI search.

How many clicks do AI Overviews take away? What the studies say

The most cited studies measure different things, but they point the same way: with an AI Overview on the page, organic CTR drops, and the top result loses the most in absolute terms. Here are the main ones, with their scope.

Study When and on what Main finding Limitation
Ahrefs, April 2025 300,000 keywords, March 2025 vs March 2024 Top result CTR 34.5% lower with an AI Overview Correlation, desktop CTR only
Ahrefs, February 2026 Same method, December 2025 vs December 2023 Top result CTR 58% lower Correlation, desktop CTR only
Seer Interactive, November 2025 (data up to September) 3,119 informational queries from 42 companies, June 2024 - September 2025 Organic CTR on queries with AI Overviews from 1.76% to 0.61% Clients of a US agency
Seer Interactive, April 2026 5.47 million queries from 53 brands, January 2025 - February 2026 Organic CTR on queries with AI Overviews from 1.3% in December 2025 to 2.4% in February 2026, below 3.2% in January 2025 One agency’s data, larger sample than the previous one and not only informational
Pew Research, July 2025 68,879 searches by 900 US adults, March 2025 Click on a result on 8% of visits with an AI summary, 15% without US only, Google disputes the method
Similarweb, July 2025 News-related searches Zero-click searches from 56% to 69% between May 2024 and May 2025 News publishing only

Ahrefs compares informational keywords with and without an AI Overview: in its first 2025 study the top result’s CTR was 34.5% lower with the box, in the 2026 update 58% lower. Both studies use aggregated Search Console data on desktop CTR. It’s a correlation between two groups of similar queries, not proof that the box causes the whole drop.

Seer Interactive tracks the CTR of its clients’ queries. In the September 2025 update organic CTR had fallen by 41% even on queries without the box, between June 2024 and September 2025, a sign that people are also looking for answers elsewhere. In the 2026 update organic CTR on queries with AI Overviews rose from about 1.3% in December 2025 to 2.4% in February 2026. On informational queries, brands cited in the box get about 120% more organic clicks per impression than brands that aren’t cited, but 38% fewer than on queries without the box.

Pew Research Center observed the real browsing of 900 US adults. According to its July 2025 study, people clicked a link inside the summary on only 1% of visits, and on 26% they ended their browsing after that page, compared with 16% without a summary.

Why do the studies give such different numbers?

Because they measure different things: Ahrefs the CTR of one position, Seer the average across its clients’ queries, Pew people’s behaviour, Similarweb a single sector. Sample, market and period change too. A 34.5% and a 58% can both be true: the second uses data from nine months later.

Two conclusions hold everywhere: the drop is real, and it’s concentrated on searches whose answer fits in a few lines. No study can give you the number for your own site.

What does Google say?

Google argues otherwise. In August 2025 Liz Reid, head of Search, wrote on Google’s blog that total organic click volume to websites is “relatively stable” year on year and that “quality” clicks, those where the user doesn’t quickly come back, have slightly increased. The post gives no figures. Google also disputed the method of Pew’s study: in a statement to Search Engine Land it called the set of searches not representative of Search traffic.

The two positions aren’t mutually exclusive: total clicks can hold steady while individual informational sites lose out.

And in Italy, how much does it weigh?

AI Overviews have been live in Italy and in Italian since 26 March 2025: Google Italy announced it, for adult users signed in to a Google account. Since October 2025 there’s also AI Mode, which we cover in the article on how to get cited by Google AI Mode.

Studies of lost clicks with a stated method and a large sample, however, are almost all American. The closest to us covers Germany: according to Sistrix, which analysed over 100 million German keywords in February 2026, the box appears on 20% of keywords and, when it does, the top result’s CTR falls from 27% to 11%. For Italy there are only estimates of how often the box appears, and they differ widely: in December 2025 SEOZoom found it on 54% of a sample of almost 30 million keywords, a study by Trovato Agency on 22.7% of 2,976 keywords across ten sectors. Sample and method differ, and neither measures clicks. On the sites we work on, the pattern matches what the studies describe: impressions stable or growing, clicks falling on guides and definitions, service and product pages less affected. The intensity varies a lot from sector to sector, which is why it’s worth measuring on your own site.

Which pages lose the most traffic?

The pages that lose most are those answering a closed question, whose answer fits in a few lines. Those that lose least are the ones used to do something: buy, request a quote, find a shop, reach the site of a company you already know.

Search type Example Likelihood of an AI Overview Exposure to the drop
Definition “what is a ghost kitchen” High High: the answer is in the box
How-to “how to clean a dishwasher filter” High High, except for long procedures or ones with video
Comparison or choice “heat pump or condensing boiler” Medium-high Medium: people who need to decide often dig deeper
Price and cost “how much does a 6 kW solar installation cost” Medium Medium: the box gives a range, buyers want a quote
Commercial “solar installation quote Turin” Low Low
Branded “[brand] shop opening hours” Low Low
Local “plumber near me” Low, the business profile is what counts Low on the site, high on the Google profile

The table sums up what emerges from the studies, which focus on informational queries, and what we see in our projects; the likelihoods are indicative. The practical point is that the same loss of clicks is worth much less on a glossary article than on a page that brings in quote requests. Before worrying about the total, look at which pages are losing.

How do you read AI Overview data in Search Console?

In Search Console, impressions and clicks from AI Overviews end up in the normal performance report, under the Web search type, together with everything else. Google says so in the documentation AI features and your website. The report has no filter to separate clicks from the box from clicks on classic results.

Three counting rules explain many oddities in the reports. They’re described in Google’s guides to impressions, position and clicks and to how data is aggregated:

  • One position for the whole box. The AI Overview takes one position on the page and all the links inside it get that same position. If the box is at the top, a page cited as the fifth source still shows up in position 1.
  • The highest position counts. If the same page appears both among the box’s sources and among the classic results, Search Console records the highest position for that search, usually the box’s. In the site view, several links to the same site on the same results page count as a single impression.
  • Standard impression rules apply. Google doesn’t give specific rules for links in AI Overviews. In general a link counts as an impression if it’s on the results page, even if the user doesn’t scroll down to it; in sections that expand, however, the impression is usually recorded only when the user opens them.

The first is the most important consequence. A page that becomes one of the sources of an AI Overview can see impressions rise and average position improve while clicks fall. That’s the pattern in our opening example: it isn’t a Search Console error, it’s how it counts.

Alongside the classic report there’s the generative AI performance report, introduced by Google on 3 June 2026 and available to all sites since 31 August 2026: it shows impressions in AI features by page, country, device and date, but not clicks, CTR or queries. What it contains and how to use it for leads we explained in the article on AI Mode and citations. Here it’s useful for one reason only: it tells you which pages appear in the boxes, and so where to look for the loss.

How to estimate the traffic you’re losing, step by step

The idea is simple: for each group of queries you calculate how many clicks you would have had at the previous CTR and compare them with actual clicks. The difference is an estimate of lost clicks, to be cleaned of other causes. Here’s the method we use.

1. Choose comparable periods

Compare the same period in two different years, for example September-October 2026 with September-October 2025, to neutralise seasonality. Search Console keeps 16 months of data: for longer comparisons, export the data every month or set up the bulk export to BigQuery. Filter by country and, if the site gets a lot of mobile traffic, look at devices separately.

2. Separate branded queries from the rest

Searches with the company name are barely affected by the box and hide the drop in the others. Since November 2025 Search Console has had a branded queries filter, available for top-level properties (not URL-path properties) with enough queries and impressions. If you don’t see it, use a query filter that excludes the company name and its variants.

3. Group queries by intent

In the performance report the query filter accepts regular expressions. To isolate informational questions, for example:

(?i)^(how|what|why|which|when|difference)\b

Create at least three groups: informational, commercial (quote, price, buy, city), branded. If the site is large, think in folders too: /blog/, /products/, /services/.

4. Find where the box appears

Search Console doesn’t tell you which queries trigger an AI Overview. You have three options, best combined:

  • the pages with the most impressions in the generative AI report are almost always those where the box appears;
  • SEO tools like Ahrefs, Semrush and SEOZoom flag keywords with AI Overviews among the results page features, with the limits of sample-based tracking;
  • for the 20-30 most important queries, a manual check, in incognito mode and on a smartphone, noting whether the box is there and whether it cites you.

5. Calculate expected and lost clicks

For each group, take the CTR from the same period a year earlier, at the same average position, and multiply it by this year’s impressions. That gives you expected clicks. The difference from actual clicks is the estimated loss.

Query group 2026 impressions 2025 CTR Expected clicks Actual clicks Estimated lost clicks
Informational with AI Overview 84,000 4.8% 4,032 1,900 2,132 (−53%)
Informational without AI Overview 21,000 4.5% 945 820 125 (−13%)
Commercial 18,000 6.2% 1,116 1,050 66 (−6%)
Branded 9,500 38% 3,610 3,580 30 (−1%)

The numbers are made up for the sake of the example.

The row that matters is the gap between the first two: both groups are informational, but only the first has the box. The drop in the second group (−13%) measures what would have happened anyway, for example because people ask those questions to ChatGPT. What’s left, about 40 points, is a reasonable estimate of the AI Overview’s weight.

If the page has become one of the box’s sources, its average position may have improved purely because of how it’s counted: compare CTR with that of the position you had before.

6. Rule out other causes

A drop in clicks can have many other explanations: an algorithm update, a lost position, a page dropped from the index, a migration, a new competitor. Before blaming it all on AI Overviews, check that page positions have stayed similar and that there are no indexing problems. If the page has lost positions, the problem lies elsewhere, and the most common reasons are in our article on why a page doesn’t rank. Search Console’s custom annotations help too: mark the dates of site changes and Google updates on the performance report chart.

How much is a lost click really worth?

A lost click on an informational guide is worth little if that guide never brought in leads. It’s worth a lot if it was the entry point for quote requests. To put an economic weight on the estimate you need two numbers from GA4 or the CRM: the conversion rate of the pages losing traffic and the average value of a lead.

An example, again with made-up numbers: the guides in the informational group converted 0.3% of visitors into enquiries. 2,132 lost clicks over two months are worth about 6 enquiries. If the commercial pages had lost the same share, 53%, that would be about 590 clicks: at a 4% rate, about 24 enquiries, four times as many. This calculation changes priorities: it often pays to protect the pages that sell and accept that some definitions will no longer bring visits.

Then there’s the part clicks don’t see: people who read your name among the sources and come back days later searching for the brand show up as branded search or direct traffic. That’s why it’s worth tracking branded queries too.

How do you get cited in an AI Overview?

Getting cited takes the same foundations as SEO: a page that is indexed, eligible to show a snippet and already ranking well, plus a passage that answers the question clearly. Google repeats this in its documentation on AI features: no special markup or dedicated files are needed. The detailed work is described in the GEO guide and in the checklist for AI search. Here we’ll stick to how to choose where to act, starting from the estimate in the previous step.

Start with queries where you’re already on page one. AI Overview sources largely come from pages Google already considers relevant. An informational query where you’re in the top ten, with the box present and no citation, is the case with the best odds.

Look at who is cited instead of you. Open the box’s sources and ask what they have that you don’t: an answer in the first lines, a table, a precise figure, a recognisable author, a recent date. Often the difference is a paragraph that answers the question in 40-60 words before any introduction.

Add what the box can’t give. An AI Overview summarises what’s already out there. Your own data, a calculator, a real example, a photo of the procedure are reasons to cite you and, for readers, reasons to click.

Work on your reputation beyond the site. Brand mentions in trade press and industry sites weigh on the choice of sources: that’s the subject of the article on digital PR and AI search.

Don’t remove the snippet to defend yourself. The nosnippet and max-snippet directives also apply to AI boxes and, since 31 August 2026, Search Console has given all sites a control to exclude the site from generative AI features in Search. But you lose the citations too. It only makes sense for restricted or paid content.

When should you stop chasing a query?

When the answer fits in two lines, no optimisation will bring back the old clicks: “what temperature to wash wool” will always get an answer in the box. There the goal becomes being the cited source, and writing time should move to searches where a full page is still needed: comparisons, choices, quotes, concrete cases. An informational page that has lost most of its visits and brings no leads should be updated and linked to the commercial pages, without writing more of the same kind. If the analysis needs to cover the whole site, the method is that of an SEO audit, with a chapter on AI answers.

Mistakes to avoid

Reading average position as if nothing had changed. With AI Overviews, all the links in the box share the same position. A better average position with fewer clicks isn’t a success to put in the report.

Applying a study’s percentage to your site. Ahrefs’ 58% refers to the top result, desktop CTR and that study’s keyword sample. Your drop may be much smaller or much larger: measure it.

Looking at total clicks. The drop on guides can hide commercial pages that are holding up, or the opposite, commercial pages in trouble. Always separate branded, informational and commercial.

Blaming every drop on AI. Algorithm updates, lost positions and technical problems do even more damage. Check position and indexing first.

Writing more generic guides to win back traffic. They’re the pages the box summarises best. Time pays off more on pages with your own data and on searches close to a decision.

Checklist for measuring the impact of AI Overviews

  1. Export the same period over two years from Search Console, for your country.
  2. Separate branded queries from the rest.
  3. Create informational, commercial and branded groups with regular expressions.
  4. Flag queries and pages with AI Overviews, using the generative AI report, an SEO tool and manual checks.
  5. Calculate expected and lost clicks for each group, comparing informational queries with and without the box.
  6. Rule out lost positions, indexing problems and Google updates.
  7. Put a value on the loss using the conversion rate of the pages involved.
  8. Pick 10-20 queries where you’re on page one but not cited, and work on those.
  9. Repeat the comparison every quarter.

Want to know how much traffic AI Overviews are costing you?

We run this analysis on your site’s data: we estimate lost clicks by query group and by page, weigh them against the leads and sales they used to bring, and check where you’re cited and where competitors appear. At the end you get a list of pages to work on, in order of value. It’s the starting point of our work on GEO.

You can book a call with Federico or write to us using the contact form.

Frequently asked questions

How much traffic do you lose with AI Overviews?

It depends on the type of query and the site. Ahrefs measured a 58% lower CTR for the top result on informational queries with an AI Overview, Pew Research a click rate almost halved. On commercial and branded searches the drop is much smaller.

Does Search Console show clicks from AI Overviews?

Not separately. Clicks from the box are included in the performance report, Web search type, together with the rest. The generative AI report only shows impressions by page, country, device and date.

Why does average position improve while clicks fall?

Because Search Console gives all the links in an AI Overview the position of the box, often the first. If the page becomes one of the sources, average position improves even when people click less.

Does being cited in an AI Overview bring clicks?

Fewer than a search without the box, but more than being left out. According to Seer Interactive’s 2026 update, on informational queries cited brands get about 120% more organic clicks per impression than those not cited, but 38% fewer than on queries without an AI Overview. On top of that, the name read in the box leads to branded searches in the following days.

Should you exclude your site from AI Overviews?

Almost never. Excluding it with nosnippet or the Search Console control doesn’t win back the clicks of people who find the answer in the box: you just stop being one of the sources. It makes sense for paid or restricted content.

Gouache illustration: a large magnifying glass shaped like a speech bubble lights up a single page among neat rows of white sheetsFREE GUIDE · 21-PAGE PDFSEO + AI Search 2026: the complete checklist for staying visible on Google and in AI answersA practical guide to making your website, content and brand findable on Google and citable by AI Overview, AI Mode, ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, with ready-made checklists and templates.Read it or download the PDF

Newsletter · a five-minute read

Found it useful? We’ll send you the next one

What we learn in our automation, data and AI projects. It takes five minutes to read, there are no sales offers in it and you can unsubscribe in one click.

What’s in the newsletter

The newsletter is sent through Brevo. Each email contains a pixel and tracked links that record whether you open it and what you click, linked to your address: we use them to understand which topics interest you and to choose what to send you (profiling). You can unsubscribe or object to profiling at any time, from the link at the bottom of every email or by writing to messaggi@digitalrunner.it.

Keep reading

RELATED ARTICLES

All about SEO & GEO

More resourcesDownloadable guidesGlossaryComparisonsAll resources

Ask for information

GEO: how would it work for you?

Tell us what you’re interested in and where you’re starting from. The person who runs this service at the agency will get back to you with timing, approach and a rough idea of costs for a case like yours.

What are you interested in for GEO?

© 2026 Digital Runner srl · Corso Valdocco 2, Torino · VAT no. 13026050016 · SDI code JI3TXCE
Privacy PolicyCookie Policy

Some of the text and images on this site are created with the help of artificial intelligence and always checked by people.

Ask for information

GEO

Someone from the team will reply within one working day.

What are you interested in for GEO?

Or call us: +39 011 19118420